香港立法者要求堵塞可能存在的漏洞,让一些专业人士可以逃避未报告虐童事件的处罚 || Hong Kong lawmakers ask for closure of potential loophole that could let some professionals escape penalty for failure to report child abuse

“To give an example, the bill mentions ‘to self proclaim an identity as a dietitian’,” legislator Lai Tung-kwok said.

“I have looked online – on the mainland, these people are not called dietitians, they are called public dietitians and are separated into four levels.

“If I call myself a public dietitian, because there is no registration system in Hong Kong and they can claim to be one, you would not be able to prosecute them.”

Audiologists are defined in the draft as a person who professes to practise as, or publishes his or her name as, an audiologist.

But other types of jobs, such as pharmacists, are defined by reference to government ordinances.

Lai raised his concerns with government officials at the meeting that the potential loophole was available to the four other categories with similar phrasing in the legislation.

The use of a Chinese phrase that means “a person who claims”, rather than a definition from the lawbooks for professionals such as pharmacists, was blamed for the potential prosecution problem.

The news came as legislators discussed the proposed law, which includes penalties of up to three months in jail and a HK$50,000 (US$6,390) fine for offenders in specific categories.

David Lam Tzit-yuen, a medical sector lawmaker, agreed with Lai’s view and that titles of the five jobs could easily be changed as they were not regulated under the law, making prosecution difficult.

“We hope you can make the definition broad enough, as this can help the children,” Lam said.

“If your definition is so narrow and the person changes their title, you can still prosecute them, but you do not decide whether they are guilty, the judge does it.

“If you have the option to adjust the bill today, is it better than arguing your case in-front of the judge?” Lam asked.

Health Bureau representatives at the meeting explained that the five roles were not regulated using government ordinances but managed through associations or voluntary registration.

Derek Lee Tung-yan, a principal assistant secretary for health, said the government had already consulted a variety of sectors when the draft was released and that authorities understood there were different opinions on interpretation.

Undersecretary for Labour and Welfare Ho Kai-ming said authorities had listened to the concerns and promised officials would look at whether amendments to the draft were required.

“We will find these five types of professionals, but how can we describe them clearly so we can protect children? We need to go back to consider this,” he added.

Lawmakers also questioned the list of professionals covered by the draft.

Judy Chan Kapui asked why private tutorial services were not included among those who would be legally required to report child abuse.

“A lot of the professionals we are talking about, say pharmacists or doctors, the time they are with children must be shorter than the time it takes for a tutorial session,” she said. “Why are we regulating some, but not others?”

Education authorities at the meeting said the list was designed to target people who had frequent contact with children and members of professions that were regulated to some extent.

They said that tutorial centres were a non-necessary service, unlike regular schools, so the coverage of schoolteachers in the draft would provide a sufficient “safety net”.

The government has to provide a response on whether it would make amendments to the bill by June 7.

Lawmakers will have time to decide whether another meeting of the bills committee is needed before the proposed legislation is put to a Legco vote.

via News - South China Morning Post (author: Harvey Kong)
 
 
Back to Top