全球投资银行前亚洲区主管称香港必须强调自己不只是另一个中国城市,并 "向权力说真话 || Former Asia head of global investment bank says Hong Kong has to underline it is not just another Chinese city and ‘speak truth to power’
“While that’s not the case in Hong Kong, at least not yet, I note, with some concern, a recent news item reporting on John Lee’s urging for Hongkongers to, quote, ‘stand united in telling others about the real and glorious side of the city’, he added.
“Something tells me that was not just a casual remark.”
Lee also asked the public to view the closure of businesses in the city with a “positive and enterprising” attitude and refrain from exaggeration of the implications.
Roach explained that the US had become reluctant to distinguish between Hong Kong and mainland China, partly due to the “clearly altered” political climate since the unrest of 2019.
“I implore all of you who want to stand up for Hong Kong, the best thing you can do is stand up for the distinction that makes this city special, to make the case that you are not just another Chinese city,” Roach told the gathering.
“And there’s a lot of things that could be said there.”
Roach in February wrote an op-ed piece called “It pains me to say Hong Kong is over” during the month-long public consultation on Hong Kong’s domestic national security legislation.
He said the piece was seen to be “so sensitive” he was “muzzled” at the China Development Forum in Beijing a month later.
“That’s too bad, mainly too bad for China,” Roach said at an event at the Foreign Correspondents’ Club in Central.
“Now, literally any debate over the, quote, ‘good stories of China’, is now provocative.”
Roach underlined the importance of preserving a culture of constructive criticism and protecting the ability to deliver uncomfortable messages, as well as the “courage that dares one to speak truth to power.”
“These messages don’t need to be taken personally,” he said. “The ability to listen to constructive criticism can deepen friendships, making intellectual adversaries better versions of themselves.
“The power of criticism, if it’s delivered effectively, need not be seen as a threat based on ulterior motives.”
Roach, also a faculty member at the Ivy League Yale University, said his appearance at the event marked the end of his fourth trip to his “second home” in the last 15 months.
He said he had been involved in “great discussions with a lot of Hongkongers” over the last few days and learned of some great ideas to boost the city’s fortunes.
But Roach reaffirmed pessimism over the Hong Kong economy.
He added the city would need to diversify and that new technologies could be its next source of strength.
But he said, with a mainland Chinese economy that would be “likely to underperform over the foreseeable future”, it would be difficult for Hong Kong to spring back to life on its own because the links between the city’s economy and the mainland’s had become tighter.
Roach said he believed the city government did not have the right political environment to come up with ideas to reverse the city’s fortunes.
“If you want to break the linkage, you’ve got to have some mechanism that would encourage spontaneous autonomy,” he told the audience.
“The politics and the influence that Beijing has in shaping your politics in the last four years don’t lend themselves to a lot in the way of independent policy initiatives that could make a difference to an economy that will struggle because of China-related linkage.”
via News - South China Morning Post (author: Kahon Chan)
“While that’s not the case in Hong Kong, at least not yet, I note, with some concern, a recent news item reporting on John Lee’s urging for Hongkongers to, quote, ‘stand united in telling others about the real and glorious side of the city’, he added.
“Something tells me that was not just a casual remark.”
Lee also asked the public to view the closure of businesses in the city with a “positive and enterprising” attitude and refrain from exaggeration of the implications.
Roach explained that the US had become reluctant to distinguish between Hong Kong and mainland China, partly due to the “clearly altered” political climate since the unrest of 2019.
“I implore all of you who want to stand up for Hong Kong, the best thing you can do is stand up for the distinction that makes this city special, to make the case that you are not just another Chinese city,” Roach told the gathering.
“And there’s a lot of things that could be said there.”
Roach in February wrote an op-ed piece called “It pains me to say Hong Kong is over” during the month-long public consultation on Hong Kong’s domestic national security legislation.
He said the piece was seen to be “so sensitive” he was “muzzled” at the China Development Forum in Beijing a month later.
“That’s too bad, mainly too bad for China,” Roach said at an event at the Foreign Correspondents’ Club in Central.
“Now, literally any debate over the, quote, ‘good stories of China’, is now provocative.”
Roach underlined the importance of preserving a culture of constructive criticism and protecting the ability to deliver uncomfortable messages, as well as the “courage that dares one to speak truth to power.”
“These messages don’t need to be taken personally,” he said. “The ability to listen to constructive criticism can deepen friendships, making intellectual adversaries better versions of themselves.
“The power of criticism, if it’s delivered effectively, need not be seen as a threat based on ulterior motives.”
Roach, also a faculty member at the Ivy League Yale University, said his appearance at the event marked the end of his fourth trip to his “second home” in the last 15 months.
He said he had been involved in “great discussions with a lot of Hongkongers” over the last few days and learned of some great ideas to boost the city’s fortunes.
But Roach reaffirmed pessimism over the Hong Kong economy.
He added the city would need to diversify and that new technologies could be its next source of strength.
But he said, with a mainland Chinese economy that would be “likely to underperform over the foreseeable future”, it would be difficult for Hong Kong to spring back to life on its own because the links between the city’s economy and the mainland’s had become tighter.
Roach said he believed the city government did not have the right political environment to come up with ideas to reverse the city’s fortunes.
“If you want to break the linkage, you’ve got to have some mechanism that would encourage spontaneous autonomy,” he told the audience.
“The politics and the influence that Beijing has in shaping your politics in the last four years don’t lend themselves to a lot in the way of independent policy initiatives that could make a difference to an economy that will struggle because of China-related linkage.”
via News - South China Morning Post (author: Kahon Chan)