香港测试发现半数家用空气净化器清除有毒甲醛的速度 "缓慢 || Hong Kong tests finds half of home air purifiers ‘slow’ at removing toxic formaldehyde
“It is easier for consumers to compare based on the CADR … so that when they look at different kinds of air purifiers, they can have a better benchmark to look into,” said Council’s chief executive Gilly Wong Fung-han.
“Of course, it is a little bit complex because the CADR requirements among different country standards are different, but still, if you are from the same market, following the same standards, it is easier to compare the performance of different models.”
The council said it and the Electrical and Mechanical Services Department tested 10 air purifiers, some of which did not display their CADR results.
The models were divided into groups and compared based on their claims of applicable room size.
The results showed models in the largest category of 60 to 100 square metres varied the most and cost was not necessarily an indicator of better performance.
The Xiaomi Pro AC-M15-SC priced at HK$1,899 (US$243) was given a higher performance score of 4.5 compared with the Dyson Purifier Big + Quiet Formaldehyde BP03, which achieved a score of 4 and cost HK$7,880.
The results were based on a variety of factors, including the Xiaomi scoring higher in CADR values at 277.6 cubic feet per minute for smoke removal, 284.5 cubic feet per minute for dust removal, and 268.6 cubic feet per minute in pollen removal.
That compared with the Dyson’s 174.7 cubic feet per minute, 188.9 cubic feet per minute and 199.8 cubic feet per minute respectively.
The Xiaomi also performed at 139.2 cubic feet per minute for formaldehyde removal compared with Dyson’s 76.7 cubic feet per minute.
Formaldehyde is a colourless, highly toxic and flammable gas mainly released in Hong Kong homes from construction materials.
The 10 models tested produced a wide range of results for its removal.
Five scored 15 cubic feet per minute or less, and an LG model managed 39.2 cubic feet per minute.
A b-MOLA device recorded 74.4 cubic feet per minute and a Panasonic machine scored 91.6 cubic feet per minute.
The watchdog, based on the test results, concluded the Dyson machine was more suited to a room of up to 25.2 square metres (271 square feet), rather than its claimed 100 square metres.
The b-MOLA BM-100 was also found to be most effective in a room of 11.5 square metres or less, instead of its advertised 70 square metres.
The tests found all the models tested underperformed based on their claimed applicable room size, although most only showed a difference of 20 square metres or less.
But the council said all the machines were “outstanding” in filtering the H1N1 influenza virus.
It added buyers should also factor in the cost of filter replacement when looking at air purifiers.
The watchdog said recommended replacement frequencies ranged from just six months to 10 years.
The council warned that people should not rely on air purifiers as a silver bullet for diseases and allergies.
“Air purifiers are helpful in improving indoor air quality, but poorly designed products or improper use may not only fail to effectively filter allergens, but also release pollutants indoors,” Victor Lam Hoi-cheung, the council’s publicity and community relations committee chairman, said.
He told the public not to “depend entirely on air purifiers for disease prevention, but also be mindful of maintaining good personal hygiene habits”.
The Post has contacted Dyson, founded in Britain, but now Singapore-based, for comment.
via News - South China Morning Post (author: Wynna Wong)
“It is easier for consumers to compare based on the CADR … so that when they look at different kinds of air purifiers, they can have a better benchmark to look into,” said Council’s chief executive Gilly Wong Fung-han.
“Of course, it is a little bit complex because the CADR requirements among different country standards are different, but still, if you are from the same market, following the same standards, it is easier to compare the performance of different models.”
The council said it and the Electrical and Mechanical Services Department tested 10 air purifiers, some of which did not display their CADR results.
The models were divided into groups and compared based on their claims of applicable room size.
The results showed models in the largest category of 60 to 100 square metres varied the most and cost was not necessarily an indicator of better performance.
The Xiaomi Pro AC-M15-SC priced at HK$1,899 (US$243) was given a higher performance score of 4.5 compared with the Dyson Purifier Big + Quiet Formaldehyde BP03, which achieved a score of 4 and cost HK$7,880.
The results were based on a variety of factors, including the Xiaomi scoring higher in CADR values at 277.6 cubic feet per minute for smoke removal, 284.5 cubic feet per minute for dust removal, and 268.6 cubic feet per minute in pollen removal.
That compared with the Dyson’s 174.7 cubic feet per minute, 188.9 cubic feet per minute and 199.8 cubic feet per minute respectively.
The Xiaomi also performed at 139.2 cubic feet per minute for formaldehyde removal compared with Dyson’s 76.7 cubic feet per minute.
Formaldehyde is a colourless, highly toxic and flammable gas mainly released in Hong Kong homes from construction materials.
The 10 models tested produced a wide range of results for its removal.
Five scored 15 cubic feet per minute or less, and an LG model managed 39.2 cubic feet per minute.
A b-MOLA device recorded 74.4 cubic feet per minute and a Panasonic machine scored 91.6 cubic feet per minute.
The watchdog, based on the test results, concluded the Dyson machine was more suited to a room of up to 25.2 square metres (271 square feet), rather than its claimed 100 square metres.
The b-MOLA BM-100 was also found to be most effective in a room of 11.5 square metres or less, instead of its advertised 70 square metres.
The tests found all the models tested underperformed based on their claimed applicable room size, although most only showed a difference of 20 square metres or less.
But the council said all the machines were “outstanding” in filtering the H1N1 influenza virus.
It added buyers should also factor in the cost of filter replacement when looking at air purifiers.
The watchdog said recommended replacement frequencies ranged from just six months to 10 years.
The council warned that people should not rely on air purifiers as a silver bullet for diseases and allergies.
“Air purifiers are helpful in improving indoor air quality, but poorly designed products or improper use may not only fail to effectively filter allergens, but also release pollutants indoors,” Victor Lam Hoi-cheung, the council’s publicity and community relations committee chairman, said.
He told the public not to “depend entirely on air purifiers for disease prevention, but also be mindful of maintaining good personal hygiene habits”.
The Post has contacted Dyson, founded in Britain, but now Singapore-based, for comment.
via News - South China Morning Post (author: Wynna Wong)