香港 "将维持由海外非常任法官担任最高法院法官的制度 || Hong Kong ‘to maintain system of having overseas non-permanent judges in top court’
Hong Kong will maintain its system of having overseas non-permanent judges sitting in its top court despite a row with an outgoing British judge whom Beijing has slammed as ‘slandering’ the rule of law, the city leader has said.
Chief Executive John Lee Ka-chiu also said on Tuesday that the remaining overseas non-permanent judges on the city’s Court of Final Appeal all had confidence in Hong Kong’s rule of law.
“About overseas judges taking part in the adjudication of cases in the Court of Final Appeal, this system will not change,” he said. “Our rule of law system will not be affected by one judge’s personal position.”
Lee, who did not name British judge Jonathan Sumption in his remarks, was asked by a reporter whether the government had reached out to express their dissatisfaction over his criticism of the judiciary and the national security law.
Over the week, Beijing’s various offices had taken aim at Sumption, who resigned from his position as an overseas non-permanent judge on the Court of Final Appeal in early June, claiming that Hong Kong was “slowly becoming a totalitarian state”.
The central government’s liaison office in Hong Kong accused Sumption of “slandering” the city’s rule of law and “blatantly violating” the practice of not commenting on ongoing proceedings.
Sumption wrote an op-ed piece in the Financial Times that the rule of law in Hong Kong had been “profoundly compromised” and judges in the city had to “operate in an impossible political environment created by China”.
The British judge had also described a recent ruling by the High Court to convict 14 of the 16 opposition figures in a landmark subversion case as “legally indefensible”.
The opinion piece and Sumption’s subsequent remarks in media interviews drew condemnation from legislators, government officials and Beijing.
Lee, in his original response to Sumption’s opinion piece, noted that the expertise of judges was based on the law and not politics, and that the city’s courts had not received any intervention in their hearing of cases.
The Hong Kong and Macau Affairs Office, which wrote two commentaries under the pen name of “Gang Ao Ping” called Sumption a “disgrace to the legal profession” for “utterly abandoning professionalism and ethics” in piece on June 13
The office posted another commentary under the same name on June 14, which said “the sound of buzzing flies cannot disrupt people’s firm confidence in Hong Kong’s rule of law”.
Lee also said on Tuesday that the remaining overseas non-permanent judges on the city’s top courts had expressed confidence in the rule of law and the ability of the judges in hearing cases professionally and without intervention.
“I believe that these voices are very loud and everyone would be able to hear it,” he said.
Sumption, 75, and British judge Lawrence Collins, 83, announced their resignations from the Court of Final Appeal earlier this month, with the latter also citing the “political situation” in Hong Kong as the reason for his departure.
Another Court of Final Appeal judge, Canadian Beverley McLachlin, 80, announced subsequently that she would retire once her term ended this summer, saying she intended to spend more time with her family.
Her departure would mean there would soon only be seven overseas non-permanent judges sitting on the city’s top bench.
via News - South China Morning Post (author: Harvey Kong)
Hong Kong will maintain its system of having overseas non-permanent judges sitting in its top court despite a row with an outgoing British judge whom Beijing has slammed as ‘slandering’ the rule of law, the city leader has said.
Chief Executive John Lee Ka-chiu also said on Tuesday that the remaining overseas non-permanent judges on the city’s Court of Final Appeal all had confidence in Hong Kong’s rule of law.
“About overseas judges taking part in the adjudication of cases in the Court of Final Appeal, this system will not change,” he said. “Our rule of law system will not be affected by one judge’s personal position.”
Lee, who did not name British judge Jonathan Sumption in his remarks, was asked by a reporter whether the government had reached out to express their dissatisfaction over his criticism of the judiciary and the national security law.
Over the week, Beijing’s various offices had taken aim at Sumption, who resigned from his position as an overseas non-permanent judge on the Court of Final Appeal in early June, claiming that Hong Kong was “slowly becoming a totalitarian state”.
The central government’s liaison office in Hong Kong accused Sumption of “slandering” the city’s rule of law and “blatantly violating” the practice of not commenting on ongoing proceedings.
Sumption wrote an op-ed piece in the Financial Times that the rule of law in Hong Kong had been “profoundly compromised” and judges in the city had to “operate in an impossible political environment created by China”.
The British judge had also described a recent ruling by the High Court to convict 14 of the 16 opposition figures in a landmark subversion case as “legally indefensible”.
The opinion piece and Sumption’s subsequent remarks in media interviews drew condemnation from legislators, government officials and Beijing.
Lee, in his original response to Sumption’s opinion piece, noted that the expertise of judges was based on the law and not politics, and that the city’s courts had not received any intervention in their hearing of cases.
The Hong Kong and Macau Affairs Office, which wrote two commentaries under the pen name of “Gang Ao Ping” called Sumption a “disgrace to the legal profession” for “utterly abandoning professionalism and ethics” in piece on June 13
The office posted another commentary under the same name on June 14, which said “the sound of buzzing flies cannot disrupt people’s firm confidence in Hong Kong’s rule of law”.
Lee also said on Tuesday that the remaining overseas non-permanent judges on the city’s top courts had expressed confidence in the rule of law and the ability of the judges in hearing cases professionally and without intervention.
“I believe that these voices are very loud and everyone would be able to hear it,” he said.
Sumption, 75, and British judge Lawrence Collins, 83, announced their resignations from the Court of Final Appeal earlier this month, with the latter also citing the “political situation” in Hong Kong as the reason for his departure.
Another Court of Final Appeal judge, Canadian Beverley McLachlin, 80, announced subsequently that she would retire once her term ended this summer, saying she intended to spend more time with her family.
Her departure would mean there would soon only be seven overseas non-permanent judges sitting on the city’s top bench.
via News - South China Morning Post (author: Harvey Kong)