福利局局长称,香港的贫困不仅与收入有关,还与生活质量有关 || Hong Kong poverty not just about income, but quality of life, welfare chief says
“The poverty line is simply a statistical concept, it does not tell you who has the needs,” he said. “Our consensus is to focus on the three target groups, which cover more than 900,000 people, and see what can be done to address their specific needs, apart from the regular social welfare.”
Since 2013, Hong Kong has used the poverty line – set at 50 per cent of median household income – to assess the poverty situation, with a detailed report released every year.
When the current administration took office in 2022, it stopped using the poverty line and updating the report. Instead, it identified the three most vulnerable groups and rolled out projects to address their specific needs.
The target groups covered 950,800 people, significantly fewer than the 1.65 million covered in the last poverty report, for 2020 and issued the following year.
Oxfam Hong Kong, which used the poverty line measurement, found 1.36 million living in poverty in the first quarter of last year, or 20 per cent of the population.
The 950,800 people identified by the government comprise 214,200 living in subdivided flats, 213,300 from single-parent families and 555,300 elderly. The total is slightly lower than the sum because of the overlap.
Some critics were concerned that the new approach narrowed the definition of poverty, excluding needy groups such as the homeless and ethnic minority members from the safety net.
But Sun set aside those concerns, saying the three target groups adequately covered people in need.
“For example, many people from ethnic minority groups are living in subdivided flats, or are from single-parent families – the more needy cases among the ethnic minorities are all covered under the new approach,” he said.
Sun said those in the target groups might not necessarily be financially poor, as some subdivided flat tenants earned a decent income and there were elderly people who owned property.
But their unmet needs compromised their well-being and prevented them from breaking out of poverty.
For example, the children of subdivided flat tenants subjected to poor living conditions often lacked social capital and needed more exposure and mentorship, according to the minister, adding income levels alone did not adequately reflect their needs.
“Hong Kong is a rich society, the kind of poverty we have is not absolute, no one is making less than US$1.50 a day,” he said. “A more practical and realistic approach is to support those target groups, and see how effective the support can be in improving their lives.”
He said the community living room project – providing subdivided flat tenants with extra living space including showers, laundries, kitchens and study rooms – had yielded far-reaching benefits.
“A mother said her mental health improved a lot, she felt happier because she developed a social circle and got to enjoy some social life there – all these benefits were intangible,” he said.
He also said an after-school care programme had not only freed parents to take up full-time jobs but also improved family relationships.
Parents could spend more quality time with their children, instead of focusing on helping with homework, which often resulted in clashes.
Sun said the government would keep track of the changes in the living quality of the three target groups to see whether the projects were effective in lifting people out of poverty.
He added that while it was challenging to measure “intangible” well-being, the government would use a multidimensional framework for its tracking and include qualitative elements.
The framework would be made public within this year, he added.
via News - South China Morning Post (author: Emily Hung)
“The poverty line is simply a statistical concept, it does not tell you who has the needs,” he said. “Our consensus is to focus on the three target groups, which cover more than 900,000 people, and see what can be done to address their specific needs, apart from the regular social welfare.”
Since 2013, Hong Kong has used the poverty line – set at 50 per cent of median household income – to assess the poverty situation, with a detailed report released every year.
When the current administration took office in 2022, it stopped using the poverty line and updating the report. Instead, it identified the three most vulnerable groups and rolled out projects to address their specific needs.
The target groups covered 950,800 people, significantly fewer than the 1.65 million covered in the last poverty report, for 2020 and issued the following year.
Oxfam Hong Kong, which used the poverty line measurement, found 1.36 million living in poverty in the first quarter of last year, or 20 per cent of the population.
The 950,800 people identified by the government comprise 214,200 living in subdivided flats, 213,300 from single-parent families and 555,300 elderly. The total is slightly lower than the sum because of the overlap.
Some critics were concerned that the new approach narrowed the definition of poverty, excluding needy groups such as the homeless and ethnic minority members from the safety net.
But Sun set aside those concerns, saying the three target groups adequately covered people in need.
“For example, many people from ethnic minority groups are living in subdivided flats, or are from single-parent families – the more needy cases among the ethnic minorities are all covered under the new approach,” he said.
Sun said those in the target groups might not necessarily be financially poor, as some subdivided flat tenants earned a decent income and there were elderly people who owned property.
But their unmet needs compromised their well-being and prevented them from breaking out of poverty.
For example, the children of subdivided flat tenants subjected to poor living conditions often lacked social capital and needed more exposure and mentorship, according to the minister, adding income levels alone did not adequately reflect their needs.
“Hong Kong is a rich society, the kind of poverty we have is not absolute, no one is making less than US$1.50 a day,” he said. “A more practical and realistic approach is to support those target groups, and see how effective the support can be in improving their lives.”
He said the community living room project – providing subdivided flat tenants with extra living space including showers, laundries, kitchens and study rooms – had yielded far-reaching benefits.
“A mother said her mental health improved a lot, she felt happier because she developed a social circle and got to enjoy some social life there – all these benefits were intangible,” he said.
He also said an after-school care programme had not only freed parents to take up full-time jobs but also improved family relationships.
Parents could spend more quality time with their children, instead of focusing on helping with homework, which often resulted in clashes.
Sun said the government would keep track of the changes in the living quality of the three target groups to see whether the projects were effective in lifting people out of poverty.
He added that while it was challenging to measure “intangible” well-being, the government would use a multidimensional framework for its tracking and include qualitative elements.
The framework would be made public within this year, he added.
via News - South China Morning Post (author: Emily Hung)