香港抨击 "完全不公平"、"误解 "的美国人口贩运报告降级 || Hong Kong hits out at ‘utterly unfair’, ‘misconceived’ US human trafficking report downgrade
Hong Kong has slammed the United States’ move to downgrade the city’s ranking in its annual report on human trafficking, saying it was “utterly unfair, misconceived, and not substantiated by facts”.
In a statement published in the early hours of Tuesday, the government said the Trafficking in Persons Report by US State Department put Hong Kong on a watch list for being unable to show that increasing efforts were made to combat the act.
“Trafficking in persons (TIP) has never been a prevalent problem in Hong Kong,” a government spokesman said.
“There has never been any sign that Hong Kong is being actively used by syndicates as a destination or transit point for [human trafficking].”
US Department of State downgraded Hong Kong from Tier 2 last year to Tier 2 Watch List in the report published on Monday local time.
The report lists five tier rankings in descending order – Tier 1, Tier 2, Tier 2 Watchlist, Tier 3 and Special Cases.
Residents in countries or regions listed under Tier 1 are the least likely to get trafficked to another place, while those listed under Special Cases are at highest risk.
The other 31 countries on the Tier 2 watch list include Laos, Nepal, Zimbabwe and Uruguay.
Mainland China and Macau came in Tier 3, a rating which indicates that no significant efforts have been made to combat human trafficking.
While governments of Tier 2 countries do not fully meet the minimum standards stated in the US Trafficking Victims Protection Act, “significant efforts” have been made to bring themselves into compliance with the benchmark, according to the report.
Countries get downgraded to the Tier 2 Watch List if the estimated number of human trafficking victims is significant or if authorities are unable to show evidence that increasing efforts have been made.
The city was upgraded to Tier 2 last year for its growing investigations and prosecutions of traffickers after being on the watch list for three consecutive years.
The government said it conducted around 11,000 initial screenings in 2023 on those vulnerable to trafficking, including illegal immigrants, sex workers, illegal workers, foreign domestic helpers and imported workers, marking a 45 per cent increase compared with 2022.
“Of note is that our heightened anti-trafficking efforts and increased number of screenings resulted in the identification of only three victims, which shows that [human trafficking] is not a prevalent or widespread issue in Hong Kong,” the spokesman said.
“It is baseless and unfair to cast doubt on our determination in combating [human trafficking] and the quality of our screenings merely because of the low number of the victims identified.”
The government also hit out at “unsubstantiated remarks” in the report about the lack of composite trafficking legislation in Hong Kong.
The spokesman said the legislative framework, which has over 50 legal provisions targeting human trafficking, provides a “comprehensive package of safeguards” comparable to other jurisdictions.
“There is no indication to suggest that the effectiveness of our anti-TIP efforts has in any way been undermined without composite trafficking legislation.”
The State Department has not published the full report yet.
via News - South China Morning Post (author: Lo Hoi-ying)
Hong Kong has slammed the United States’ move to downgrade the city’s ranking in its annual report on human trafficking, saying it was “utterly unfair, misconceived, and not substantiated by facts”.
In a statement published in the early hours of Tuesday, the government said the Trafficking in Persons Report by US State Department put Hong Kong on a watch list for being unable to show that increasing efforts were made to combat the act.
“Trafficking in persons (TIP) has never been a prevalent problem in Hong Kong,” a government spokesman said.
“There has never been any sign that Hong Kong is being actively used by syndicates as a destination or transit point for [human trafficking].”
US Department of State downgraded Hong Kong from Tier 2 last year to Tier 2 Watch List in the report published on Monday local time.
The report lists five tier rankings in descending order – Tier 1, Tier 2, Tier 2 Watchlist, Tier 3 and Special Cases.
Residents in countries or regions listed under Tier 1 are the least likely to get trafficked to another place, while those listed under Special Cases are at highest risk.
The other 31 countries on the Tier 2 watch list include Laos, Nepal, Zimbabwe and Uruguay.
Mainland China and Macau came in Tier 3, a rating which indicates that no significant efforts have been made to combat human trafficking.
While governments of Tier 2 countries do not fully meet the minimum standards stated in the US Trafficking Victims Protection Act, “significant efforts” have been made to bring themselves into compliance with the benchmark, according to the report.
Countries get downgraded to the Tier 2 Watch List if the estimated number of human trafficking victims is significant or if authorities are unable to show evidence that increasing efforts have been made.
The city was upgraded to Tier 2 last year for its growing investigations and prosecutions of traffickers after being on the watch list for three consecutive years.
The government said it conducted around 11,000 initial screenings in 2023 on those vulnerable to trafficking, including illegal immigrants, sex workers, illegal workers, foreign domestic helpers and imported workers, marking a 45 per cent increase compared with 2022.
“Of note is that our heightened anti-trafficking efforts and increased number of screenings resulted in the identification of only three victims, which shows that [human trafficking] is not a prevalent or widespread issue in Hong Kong,” the spokesman said.
“It is baseless and unfair to cast doubt on our determination in combating [human trafficking] and the quality of our screenings merely because of the low number of the victims identified.”
The government also hit out at “unsubstantiated remarks” in the report about the lack of composite trafficking legislation in Hong Kong.
The spokesman said the legislative framework, which has over 50 legal provisions targeting human trafficking, provides a “comprehensive package of safeguards” comparable to other jurisdictions.
“There is no indication to suggest that the effectiveness of our anti-TIP efforts has in any way been undermined without composite trafficking legislation.”
The State Department has not published the full report yet.
via News - South China Morning Post (author: Lo Hoi-ying)