香港牙医管理委员会称对香港牙医的资格要求 "并非任意强加 || Qualification requirements for Hong Kong dentists ‘not arbitrarily imposed’, council says

AI Summary:

---------------

"理事会解释说:"对临床经验的要求不是理事会单方面或任意强加的,而是在与教师协商后制定的。

该理事会补充说,这一过程参考了海外文献、经验和不同司法管辖区的评审规则,以及香港课程的设计,以 "确保各项要求可以实现"。

2019 年的变化包括牙科学生必须治疗过至少 50 名五种不同类型的病人,并完成 20 种牙科手术的最低数量,才有资格在该市工作。

但弗莱米格质疑增加的要求是否准确反映了学生的能力。

然而,理事会表示,认证要求涉及质量和数量,"与媒体报道中引用的言论相矛盾"。

"补充说:"临床经验的量化要求并不是评审工作的唯一评估标准。

四月份,政府提出为城市毕业生提供为期一年的实习机会,以增加他们的临床经验,此后,牙医的培训成为焦点。

官员们表示,有必要进行修改,以解决理事会提出的关切问题。

其中包括港大牙科本科课程临床培训的结构性问题,这些问题已列入2014年、2019年和2023年的评审报告。

委员会还表示,一些学生的临床经验 "严重不足",在特定牙科手术方面 "毫无经验"。

弗莱米格早些时候说,Covid-19 大流行扰乱了临床教学。

问题包括教学医院长达数月的关闭,导致学生难以达到理事会的要求。

理事会周四表示,它理解大流行病造成的问题,因此为该学院提供了一个 "纠正违规行为 "的机会。

"理事会还说:"托马斯-弗莱米格教授......称 Covid-19 大流行病是媒体报道中引述的未能达到要求的辩护理由,理事会对此感到困惑和不解。

理事会表示,自2012年以来,它一直就评审工作中的临床培训问题与该学院进行沟通,并要求其采取补救措施,但该学院并未做出任何重大改变。

它还补充说,2023 届城市牙科毕业生全部达到临床要求的说法是不真实的。

理事会称,理事会主席李健民博士与牙科学院代理院长金立坚教授会面,讨论了评审工作。
---------------

“[The] requirements of clinical experience are not unilaterally or arbitrarily imposed by the council, but rather were developed in consultation with the faculty,” it explained.

The council added that the process took into account overseas literature, experience and accreditation rules in a variety of jurisdictions, as well as the design of the Hong Kong curriculum, to “ensure the requirements would be achievable”.

The 2019 changes included the need for dental students to have treated at least 50 patients of five different types, and perform minimum numbers in 20 types of dental procedures before they were qualified to work in the city.

But Flemmig questioned if the added requirements accurately reflected the competence of students.

The council, however, said the accreditation requirements involved quality and quantity, which were “contradictory to the quoted remarks as reported in media coverage”.

“The quantitative requirement of clinical experience is not the only assessment criterion in the accreditation exercise,” it added.

The training of dentists came under the spotlight in April after the government proposed one-year internships for city graduates to boost their clinical experience.

Officials said the changes were needed to tackle concerns raised by the council.

These included structural problems with clinical training in HKU’s undergraduate dentistry programme, which were included in accreditation reports from 2014, 2019 and 2023.

The council also said some students had “severely inadequate” clinical experience and “zero experience” in particular dental procedures.

Flemmig earlier said the Covid-19 pandemic had disrupted clinical teaching.

Problems included the months-long closure of the teaching hospital, which made it difficult for students to meet the council’s requirements.

The council said on Thursday that it understood the problems caused by the pandemic, so it had offered an opportunity for the faculty to “rectify the non-compliances”.

“The council is confused and puzzled by the remarks made by Professor Thomas Flemmig … that the Covid-19 pandemic was a defence for the failure to meet the requirements as quoted in the media reports,” it added.

The council said it had been in communication with the faculty about clinical training problems during accreditation exercises since 2012 and had asked it to take remedial action, but the faculty had not made any significant changes.

It added the claim that all 2023 city dental graduates had met clinical requirements was untrue.

The council said Dr Lee Kin-man, the council chairman, met Professor Jin Lijian, the acting dean of the dental faculty, to discuss the accreditation exercise.

via News - South China Morning Post (author: Emily Hung)
 
 
Back to Top