|| Floods, corruption, lax maintenance take toll on India’s creaking bridges: ‘lucky that no one died’

AI Summary:

---------------

---------------

“It is monsoon time. There has been an abnormal amount of rain, which is the reason behind the collapse of bridges,” said federal minister Jitan Ram Manjhi, who earlier suspected a “conspiracy” behind the disaster.

Nitish Kumar, Bihar’s longest-serving chief minister, held a high-level meeting this week to take control of the situation and suspended 16 senior bureaucrats for dereliction of duty in maintaining the bridges.

On Monday, Kumar also hurriedly launched a bridge-specific maintenance policy that was in the works for nearly a decade.

The new rule mandates two inspections every year, and each bridge will have a “health card” with comprehensive details of its maintenance.

“Certain portions of bridges/causeways that caved in … are very old. These structures don’t seem to have been constructed following the required parameters,” said Chaitanya Prasad, a senior government official following the meeting.

“It also appears that the foundation was not deep enough, a reason why these structures got damaged during floods.”

The deluge-prone agrarian state, home to 21 rivers, has about 30 large and 1,200 small bridges.

Though no casualties were reported in any of the collapses yet, the Supreme Court has been urged to order the Bihar administration to undertake a structural study of all the bridges.

“Back-to-back collapse of the bridges in Bihar clearly indicates that there have been no lessons learned, and safety of critical infrastructure like bridges is not taken seriously. These routine incidents cannot be termed merely accidents; they are man-made disasters,” Brajesh Singh, the petitioner, said.

Complex reasons

Between 1977 and 2017, more than 2,130 bridges collapsed during various stages of construction across India, according to a study published in 2020.

It found the average age of failure of bridges was 34.5 years, a low duration compared to the expected design life.

The report’s lead author, Rajeev Kumar Garg, said the combined reasons of poor construction techniques and excessive flooding could have caused the bridges to collapse.

“In recent bridge failure cases, the bridges are small, and the flood is intense. Apparently, it can be said that the conjecture of inappropriate (type or weak) foundation coupled with intense flood caused the collapse,” he told This Week in Asia.

“Where the foundation is intact, then the superstructure (deck) was aged and weak and so collapsed,” said Garg, a researcher with New Delhi’s CSIR-Central Road Research Institute.

Amitabha Ghoshal, former president of the industry body Consulting Engineers Association of India, said multiple factors including faulty construction, bridge overuse and irregular maintenance could have played a role in the disaster.

“Many failures happen during construction, as the bridge structure is incomplete at that stage and unable to resist the unplanned forces imposed by unskilled construction teams,” said Ghoshal, who has more than six decades of experience in the construction of bridges.

While the design is checked and rechecked for the forces coming during its service life, the authorities seldom get the proper design done for the various stages of construction, he added.

Ghoshal said “acceptance of poor quality is prevalent in our corruption-ridden society” and the practice of awarding new contracts to companies with a history of failures because of their proximity to powerful politicians was common.

He called for systematic and scientific bridge health monitoring systems to prevent fresh mishaps.

A senior member of the Bihar Engineers Association, who did not wish to be identified, said rampant graft was chiefly behind the recent collapse of bridges that were all built by sub-par “corrupt” contractors close to those in power.

“It’s only lucky that no one has died so far.”

via News - South China Morning Post (author: Vasudevan Sridharan)
 
 
Back to Top