|| Hong Kong Victoria Harbour protection group vows to close if changes to reclamation law go ahead

AI Summary:

---------------

---------------

A green group that has fought to protect Hong Kong’s Victoria Harbour for nearly 30 years has vowed to dissolve if the government pushes ahead with a proposed legal amendment that could pave the way for large-scale reclamation.

The Society for Protection of the Harbour said on Friday it would wind down its operations if the Legislative Council approved the change to the Protection of the Harbour Ordinance.

Authorities have said they will present a bill within the year to facilitate reclamation in Victoria Harbour.

Society vice-chairman Winston Chu Ka-sun said the group would be left with few options to continue its fight.

“If we lose the battle, there’s nothing left for the society to do … We will no longer have any say over the ordinance and we cannot control the government,” the 84-year-old said. “It will just be a waste of time. We shall put an end to our operation.”

The group sent a letter to Secretary for Justice Paul Lam Ting-kwok on Friday to demand the legal justification behind the proposed amendment, also taking out an advertisement in the print edition of the Post to publicise its move.

The society, which has campaigned for 29 years, said the proposed change would effectively abolish legal protections for the harbour.

It added that the government would become “a judge of its own cause” by proposing and deciding on reclamation projects, which it said went against the fundamental principle of natural justice.

The legal principle commonly arises in procedural safeguards, such as the right to a fair hearing, the right to appeal a decision which has already been made, the need for impartiality and the protection of legitimate expectations, according to the Community Legal Information Centre.

Chu founded the society in 1995 to protect the harbour against excessive reclamation, leading to the enactment of the ordinance in 1997.

The existing legal regime bans reclamation in Victoria Harbour unless the government proves to a court that a project has an “overriding public need” and is supported by “cogent and convincing materials”.

But authorities have proposed categorising the works into large- and small-scale reclamation in a bid to advance development of the harbourfront. A third category will govern temporary works.

Under the changes, the government will still need to prepare materials to present to the public and other stakeholders for large-scale projects. The chief executive and his advisers must then provide the final approval.

The changes affecting small-scale projects, defined as being 0.8 hectares (2 acres) in size or less, will allow authorities to bypass public consultation and go directly to the government-appointed Harbourfront Commission advisory body and district councillors. The final decision on whether to proceed will rest with the financial secretary.

Chu said the proposed amendments were “irresponsible” as the government would no longer need to prove the lawfulness of its projects to a court.

Instead, members of the public, who had much fewer resources, would have to prove a reclamation proposal was unlawful.

The advocacy group said it would gauge public views over designating Victoria Harbour as a “national treasure” to enhance its protection, adding it would take the proposal to mainland Chinese authorities if it garnered widespread support.

The Post has reached out to the justice minister and the Development Bureau for comment.

via News - South China Morning Post (author: Edith Lin)
 
 
Back to Top