由于 "分歧较大 "和时机问题,中国可能放弃统一的人工智能立法 || China likely to ditch unified AI legislation due to ‘considerable disagreement’, timing

AI Summary:

---------------

上周五,在由清华大学人文社会科学高等研究院、联合国可持续发展解决方案网络和孟子基金会联合主办的 "古代智慧应对现代挑战 "孔子与亚里士多德研讨会期间,郑永年在北京发表了上述讲话。

中国一直在起草自己的人工智能立法,根据其 5 月份公布的年度立法工作计划,一部统一的法律草案已提交中国最高立法机构--全国人大常委会审议。

但 Zheng 表示,提交的文件仅处于非常早期的阶段,草案也没有时间表,这表明缺乏进展。

Zheng 表示,由于人工智能技术在不断快速发展,因此要推出的法规将针对具体部门或行业。

在今年 3 月举行的一年一度的 "两会 "期间,商界和政界精英就如何制定人工智能法规和法律提出了不同的建议。

全国人大代表、中国移动河南分公司董事长娄向平呼吁为人工智能建立 "系统的法律和监管框架"。不过,据中国媒体报道,全国政协委员、金杜律师事务所北京分所高级合伙人张毅提醒说,"过激的法律干预可能会抑制人工智能的健康有序发展"。

上海交通大学的 Zheng 说,考虑到人工智能的飞速发展及其带来的潜在风险,与欧盟和美国相比,中国在制定人工智能法律时可能会采取更加平衡的方法。

"一方面,我们希望促进人工智能的发展,因为发展是中国的一个重要主题。另一方面,我们也不希望这项技术带来大规模的负面影响,"他说。

欧盟的人工智能法案将人工智能系统分为不可接受、高、有限和最低风险等级,并对组织开发人工智能提出了不同的规定和要求。该法案还禁止被视为 "对人的认知行为操纵"、"被视为对人的威胁 "的技术。

Zheng 表示,这种禁令对中国的科技行业来说 "非常不现实",因为 "人工智能或多或少会操纵人类行为,包括最简单的推荐算法"。

Zheng 补充说,美国没有,也不打算制定这样的法律,因为美国社会鼓励创新和市场增长,而欧盟执行更严格的法规不仅是为了保护个人权利,也是为了限制占主导地位的美国公司,因为欧盟在科技领域相对较弱。

随着欧盟在人工智能监管方面走在前列,人工智能的机遇和风险迅速将这项技术推上了大国会议的外交议程。
---------------

Zheng made the remarks last Friday in Beijing on the sidelines of the Confucius and Aristotle Symposium on Ancient Wisdom for Modern Challenges, which was jointly hosted by the Tsinghua Institute for Advanced studies in Humanities and Social Sciences, the UN Sustainable Development Solutions Network, and the Mencius Foundation.

China has been drawing up its own AI legislation and a draft of a unified law was submitted for review to the country’s top legislative body, the National People’s Congress (NPC) Standing Committee, according to its annual legislative work plan made public in May.

But Zheng said the submission was only at a very early stage and there was no timetable for the draft, which suggested a lack of progress.

Zheng said that instead, the regulations to be rolled out would be sector or industry-specific, since AI technologies were constantly and quickly evolving.

During the annual “two sessions” gathering in March, business and political elites tabled divergent proposals on how to establish AI regulations and laws.

Lou Xiangping, an NPC representative and chairman of the Henan branch of China Mobile, called for building a “systematic legal and regulatory framework” for AI. However, Zhang Yi, a member of the Chinese People’s Political Consultative Conference and senior partner at the Beijing office of law firm King & Wood Mallesons, cautioned that “overbearing legal interventions could inhibit the healthy and orderly development of AI”, according to reports from Chinese media outlets.

Zheng, with Shanghai Jiao Tong University, said China may strike a more balanced approach to AI lawmaking compared to the EU and the United States, considering AI’s rapid advances and the potential risks it entails.

“On one hand, we want to promote the development of artificial intelligence, as development is a key theme for China. On the other hand, we do not want this technology to bring about large-scale negative impacts,” he said.

The EU’s AI act has classified AI systems into unacceptable, high, limited and minimal risk levels and offered different regulations and requirements for organisations to develop AI. It has also banned technology considered “cognitive behavioural manipulation of people” that is “considered a threat to people”.

Zheng said such a ban would be “very unrealistic” for China’s tech industries as “AI manipulates human behaviours more or less, including the simplest recommendation algorithms”.

Zheng added that the US does not have, nor does it intend to have, such a law as its society encourages innovation and market growth, while the EU enforces stricter regulations not only to protect individual rights but also to restrict dominant American companies due to the EU’s relative weakness in the tech sector.

The opportunities and risks of AI have quickly pushed the technology onto diplomatic agendas in meetings between the major powers as the EU has taken the lead in AI regulation.

via News - South China Morning Post (author: Sylvie Zhuang)
 
 
Back to Top